The following are lessons I have learned from being in situations in which I am the confidant, consultant, or otherwise unwilling ear to two different parties who both confide in me about the same thing. Usually, said “thing” is the other person in the drama. Let me break it down. There is Party A, who has a problem with Party B (or vice versa), who then talks to Party C: me.
I hate drama. A lot. And I hate when people would rather talk about other people than simply have a civil face-to-face discussion about their problems with one another. Similarly, I hate being friends with BOTH Party A and Party B, because that causes a conflict of interest in me that is rather difficult to overcome. I usually like to listen to people’s problems – it’s part of my ethos. But in situations like this, things get complicated, frustrating, and downright unhealthy – usually for Party C (again, that’s me). So, here we go.
Lessons on Being the Middle Man
1. Party A’s version of the story will conflict with Party B’s version. There’s no way around it. You will want to clear up the details, but wait…you’re supposed to be the confidant to both of them, remember?
2. When talking with one of the Parties, you will accidentally slip up and reveal more than you are supposed to know. Now you’re in an awkward situation, and you must cover.
3. Party A will claim that he/she doesn’t care about the situation. Party B will insist that Party A is torn up about the situation. Naturally.
4. Both Parties will inevitably say, “Don’t tell anyone I told you this” or some variation on that.
5. You will want to help the situation, but you must resist! As the middle man, you are nearly powerless.
5a. Your version of “help” probably includes somehow taking sides. Unless there is someone clearly in the wrong (e.g., a crime is committed), there is no way you can fairly “help” the situation. And forget about your personal beliefs; they do not matter.
6. At least one of the Parties will almost definitely feel betrayed by you somehow. And you will find that that Party trusts you less than they did beforehand.
7. Remember, you are not a mediator, and this is not your battle to fight.
8. When Party A questions Party B on how you know certain information, Party B’s explanation will likely be a simple, usually inaccurate, “Because he asked.”
8a. The Party who claims, “Because he asked,” probably got you involved by dropping vague hints and provocative statements, the meanings of which would not have been understood unless you had questioned them.
9. It is quite possible you will be made into a scapegoat, with all bad feelings shifting to you so that Party A and Party B can move on to fight another fight.
10. Your final reflection on the situation will leave you feeling any number of the following: I am untrustworthy, I only made the situation worse, I’m not a good friend, I really didn’t help anything, Why does this keep happening?, I am not here to hold anyone’s hands, I don’t understand these people, Open and honest is rather refreshing – why can’t they try it?, They’ll be fine but I’ll be alone, and/or Damn – here I am again to clean up a mess.
Remember, these rules may vary for you. I know that my experience in this kind of circumstance tends toward the negative, and usually I just feel really, really bad about myself when all is said and done. I suppose it just comes with the territory. But take notes, people. When Party A and Party B tangle you in their web of secrecy, power struggle, and repressed emotion, it’s hard to escape. Particularly if you, like me, genuinely want to help. But that word – help – is just too ambiguous, and who are you to determine what’s helpful and what’s best?
So forget petty drama. Forget heavy drama. Stay out of people’s business. You can’t be friends with everyone, and sometimes, you can’t help one Party without hurting the other. And afterwards, all you will have done is cause a burden on one Party, or uncomfortable explanations for another. It’s not worth it. Be a friend, but keep your self-respect, fight your own battles, and for Christ’s sake, let people solve their own goddamn problems. Chin up, move on.
Oh, I forgot to tell you, this will be on the test.